Site Meter Reflections on Playboy: Something greater than oneself? Yes! The government? No!

October 10, 2008

Something greater than oneself? Yes! The government? No!

John McCain has always given me the creeps. He sincerely loves his country, but he is too much of a true believer in the miraculous powers of government to be trusted as the executive custodian of his country’s freedom-loving heritage. For example, the notion that young adults of any generation need to be enslaved and infantilized by compulsory “national service” is as un-American as anything.

Being a student of the transcendent teachings of A Course in Miracles, I have qualified respect for the spirit of self-transcendence that helped McCain endure imprisonment in Vietnam. However, nothing in an honest appraisal of history, economics, and human psychology can justify McCain’s quasi-religious faith in government as the alternative to the petty concerns of the individual ego. Barack Obama is less libertarian than my ideal candidate for president would be, but he doesn’t seem to go as far as McCain in viewing government as the Jiminy Cricket to everyone’s Pinocchio.*

One of the justifications for the separation of church and state is that the state only flatters itself when it calls itself a worthy teacher of anything to anyone. Oscar Wilde caught the gist of this wisdom when he said that nothing worth knowing can be taught. If McCain doesn’t like it when his fellow Americans give themselves to frivolous or selfish pursuits, he should admit that they won’t find wisdom any faster as a consequence of government action. Even the state’s power to imprison ought to be seen as merely a pragmatic deterrent, not a pedagogical tool—or else the system is abused.

McCain wishes to use government to lay an Adbusters-style guilt trip on American hedonism and consumerism. But if the acquisition of wisdom can never be rushed, the only sensible option is to let individuals party until they wear themselves out. Why does Obama struggle to live down a reputation as a flaky idealist when, between the two of them, McCain puts up a bigger fight against reality?

*Update, November 7, 2008, 2:06 p.m.: Maybe I spoke too soon on the Jiminy Cricket thing. In any event, don’t blame me. I voted for Bob Barr.

Posted by Brian Sorgatz at 1:11 PM

Post a Comment

« Home

Create a Link