Site Meter Reflections on Playboy: What does cruelty look like?

August 6, 2007

What does cruelty look like?

Obviously, and for the same reasons, my question makes no more sense than Noam Chomsky’s inspired sentence-as-thought-experiment Colorless green ideas sleep furiously. But the anniversary of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima in 1945 forces me to think about it seriously as a U.S. citizen and a human being.

Christianity, Islam, and (by interpretation) the Bhagavad Gita have all sometimes made philosophically sophisticated cases for the possibility of just warfare. But let’s face something unpleasant about that: Whenever said possibility is conceded, the untangling of the legitimate moral questions surrounding a given act of war can sometimes last for generations on both sides of the conflict. Worse yet, the questions can arise over a massive range of military, political, technological, and diplomatic circumstances. Much of my earlier respect for Abraham Lincoln has been lost to the fact that he authorized the federal government’s first draft, which is slavery whether anyone dare call it that. And if President Truman can be grilled for lack of imagination and integrity in fighting the bloodthirsty Japanese, why not hold Lincoln to the same standard in fighting slavery?

Absolute pacifism is not the only answer, but difficult questions are the only alternative to absolute pacifism.

These excerpts from a 2005 BBC documentary series on World War II make the Hiroshima question as philosophically bewildering as anything, which probably means they answer my question about as well as anything:

Labels: , , ,


Posted by Brian Sorgatz at 5:44 PM

  • Blogger Brandon left this comment at August 14, 2007 9:21 AM  
    Living peacefully definitely is something that takes slow, meticulous consideration. I do not support war in any form. However, I cannot and willonot say that I am nonviolent. I am anti-aggression. But I believe infighting back when someone is at your throat. As June Jordan said- "I am not wrong, wrong is not my name, my name is my own my own my own and I can't tell you who in the hell set things up like this but I can tell you that from now on in my self-determination and in my simple daily and nightly resistance it may very well cost you your life." My quote="Castration is the key to our liberation."
  • Post a Comment

    « Home

    Create a Link