Site Meter Reflections on Playboy: Another Playboy model may be punished for her courage

April 13, 2007

Another Playboy model may be punished for her courage

24-year-old Adriana Dominguez, a third-year student at Brooklyn Law School, took her clothes off for the Playboy TV series Naked Happy Girls. (The Playboy Cyber Club has extra video footage of its own, but a paid subscription is required.) The New York Daily News reports:
“I wanted to do something a little crazy before I graduate and do become a lawyer...do something kind of out of character,” Dominguez said with a grin as she posed for photographer Andrew Einhorn inside his friend’s DUMBO [“Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass”] apartment.

“Lawyers can be boring,” [she] later added.

But no one will ever call Dominguez buttoned-up.

....

When she made the erotic video, Dominguez, a California native, seemed unfazed by the idea that it could wreck her future.

“I’m not that shy, so it wouldn’t bother me if, say, the opposing counsel has seen these pictures of me. I wouldn’t care,” she told Einhorn after he asked her if she had any concerns.

“When we shot, she knew what might happen down the road if these pictures might get shown to people in her field,” Einhorn told The News.

“But she had this self-confidence to not let that bother her. I don’t think that she felt that this would be negative in any way to her career,” he said.

The sexy stunt could have dire consequences for the would-be lawyer.

If she applies for the New York State Bar this year, Dominguez could face tough questions from the Committee on Character and Fitness, which examines the personal character of future lawyers.

“It may have an effect. It’s a possibility in the worst-case scenario that the person does not get admitted,” a committee representative said.

And potential employers are sure to discover Dominguez’s striptease with a quick Internet search.

Except for her naughty past, Dominguez has plenty to recommend her: she had a fall internship with the domestic violence unit of the Brooklyn district attorney’s office and served as treasurer of her law school’s Legal Association of Activist Women.
This blog takes the admittedly romantic view that the sheer boldness of this woman’s Playboy gig is cause for celebration in itself. Fortunately, her career in law may still have a fighting chance, as libertarian blogger Eugene Volokh explains:
I would surely not advise would-be lawyers—or almost anyone who doesn’t really really need the money—to pose naked in Playboy TV series. Rightly or wrongly, such behavior may make employers and clients think the less of you.

This having been said, it seems to me that it would be a clear First Amendment violation for a state bar to consider this in the character and fitness evaluation. The government, even in its capacity as licensor, generally may not penalize you for exercise of your First Amendment rights; and making sexually themed videos is part of your First Amendment rights just as is making other videos (at least unless the videos are child pornography or are such hard-core porn that they fit within the category of obscenity).
As usual, the most disappointing angle of the story is some feminists’ sloppy cause-and-effect reasoning about pornography and violence against women, as when they question Dominguez’ integrity as a feminist. (Does that kind of feminist ever get embarrassed about being arguably more uptight than The Wall Street Journal?) The trick to preventing violence is consistently punishing it. Will the New York legal establishment punish Dominguez for her nonviolent peccadillo, or will it recognize her intelligence, ambition, and self-confidence as powerful weapons against violence?

Update, June 24, 2007, 4:25 p.m.: If you followed the former link to the free video clip very long after I published this post, you may have seen a woman other than Dominguez. Today, I discovered that the URL contained a video of somebody else and deleted the link.

Posted by Brian Sorgatz at 11:16 AM

  • Blogger Omar left this comment at April 25, 2007 3:17 AM  
    Dude she's a slut, this is insanity. Most of the west's problems (sexualistation, single motherhood (and the corresponding spike in crime) and the decline in high culture) can be traced back to the falling away of that most useful of social forces - shame. Shame was the greatest weapon society had against chaos and old night, and we've thrown it away. A society that doesn't judge people is a sick one.
  • Blogger Brian Sorgatz left this comment at April 25, 2007 9:47 AM  
    OK, Omar. For a healthier society, I’ll do my part by passing judgment on you. Western civilization is doing very well for itself by ignoring idiots like you. Violence continues to decline. Overall, things are getting better, not worse. A sense of individual liberty and delight in the naked human body go all the way back to the ass-kicking ancient Greeks. How many thousands of years do you think the West has been in decline, anyway?
  • Post a Comment

    « Home

    Create a Link